Appalachian elktoe surviving but not thriving in streams struck by tropical storms Fred and Helene

Written By

Asheville, N.C. - The line of bright-orange spray paint on the log that dipped into West Fork of the Pigeon River was hard to miss, but that was the point.

The tag was placed by aquatic biologists with the N.C. Wildlife Resources Commission as a sign to heavy equipment operators extracting stream debris in the wake of Tropical Storm Helene. The message? Leave this log, it鈥檚 important for a healthy stream. While foreign objects like refrigerators, shipping containers, dumpsters, even entire cars found their way into area streams during storm flooding, and definitely warranted extraction, downed wood, often referred to as woody debris, is a natural and normal part of a healthy stream. It can protect banks from erosion, subtly shift water flow to create micro-habitats for stream life, and support the stream food chain by providing a substrate for algal growth and capturing leaves eaten by aquatic insects that are, in-turn, eaten by fish. Generally, woody material in a stream only requires attention in discrete situations such as logs piling up against a bridge or significant log jams.

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biologists Jay Mays (L) and Byron Hamstead prepare to snorkel the East Fork of the Pigeon River.

Streams of the Pigeon River watershed, in Haywood County, N.C. were struck hard by Tropical Storm Fred in 2021 and then again in 2024 by Helene. On a recent morning in peak summer, a team of three U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biologists donned snorkel gear and hit both the east and west forks of the Pigeon River. The trio were in search of endangered Appalachian elktoe mussels, a species found only in a handful of streams in Southern Appalachia. This outing offered a glimpse of how the mussels faired through Helene and provided biologists with knowledge of the current on-the-ground situation to inform decisions on upcoming bridge replacements. 

Biologists approach the East Fork of the Pigeon River to begin a search for endangered Appalachian elktoe mussels.

In a nod to Helene鈥檚 impacts, the team quickly pulled a hatchet, sledgehammer, maul, and fishing net from the East Fork of the Pigeon River, though no mussels were found. The biologists鈥� search of the west fork was disappointingly empty handed until they came upon an area that yielded roughly forty of the endangered mussels 鈥� a sweet spot around the log tagged with orange spray paint. Another sweet spot was found further upstream of one of the bridges slated for replacement, bringing the day鈥檚 total to nearly fifty. The number was good, but the individuals were concentrated in isolated pockets, not more widely distributed across the river in a way that would be more indicative of a vibrant, healthy stream. The outing was another small step in a long journey to reveal how Tropical Storm Helene impacted the area鈥檚 rarest flora and fauna.

Byron Hamstead dives to get a closer look at the stream bottom, where any mussels would be found.
Byron Hamstead snorkels the East Fork of the Pigeon River in search of Appalachian elktoe mussels.
Mark Endries (L) and Byron Hamstead scout the West Fork of the Pigeon River before snorkeling in search of Appalachian elktoe mussels.
Jay Mays (L) and Byron Hamstead snorkeling the West Fork of the Pigeon River. 
Byron Hamstead snorkeling past a log marked to keep it from being removed during efforts to clean debris from Tropical Storm Helene.
A pair of river chub swim past an Appalachian elktoe mussel.
An Appalachian elktoe mussel in the West Fork of the Pigeon River, Haywood County, N.C.
Byron Hamstead taking a moment at the end of a search for Appalachian elktoe mussels. 

Story Tags

Biologists (USFWS)
Monitoring
Rivers and streams
Snorkeling

Recreational Activities